This study sought to understand athletic therapists’ perspectives on the psychological challenges athletes experience during injury recovery and to assess their perceived level of preparedness in addressing these challenges. Using an online survey, 49 certified athletic therapists from across Canada reported they are aware of the psychological challenges facing injured athletes and believe they play a role in assisting injured athletes in their psychological recovery. However, the results indicated that athletic therapists do not feel adequately prepared to provide this support and recommended more exposure to content related to psychological aspects of injury in their education.