Introduction: Device-based monitors often classify all sedentary positions as the sitting posture, but sitting with bent or straight legs may exhibit unique physiological and biomechanical effects. The classifications of the specific nuances of sitting have not been understood. The purpose of this study was to validate a dual-monitor approach from a trimonitor configuration measuring knee-flexion angles compared to motion capture (criterion) during sitting in laboratory setting. Methods: Nineteen adults (12♀, 24 ± 4 years) wore three activPALs (torso, thigh, tibia) while 14 motion capture cameras simultaneously tracked 15 markers located on bony landmarks. Each participant completed a 45-s supine resting period and eight, 45-s seated trials at different knee flexion angles (15° increment between 0° and 105°, determined via goniometry), followed by 15 s of standing. Validity was assessed via Friedman’s test (adjusted p value = .006), mean absolute error, Bland–Altman analyses, equivalence testing, and intraclass correlation. Results: Compared to motion capture, the calculated angles from activPALs were not different during 15°–90° (all, p ≥ .009), underestimated at 105° (p = .002) and overestimated at 0°, as well as the supine position (both, p < .001). Knee angles between 15° and 105° exhibited a mean absolute error of ∼5°, but knee angles <15° exhibited larger degrees of error (∼10°). A proportional (β = −0.12, p < .001) bias was observed, but a fixed (0.5° ± 1.7°, p = .405) bias did not exist. In equivalence testing, the activPALs were statistically equivalent to motion capture across 30°–105°. Strong agreement between the activPALs and motion capture was observed (intraclass correlation = .97, p < .001). Conclusions: The usage of a three-activPAL configuration detecting seated knee-flexion angles in free-living conditions is promising.
Search Results
You are looking at 1 - 2 of 2 items for
- Author: Ryan J. Frayne x
- Refine by Access: All Content x
Criterion Validity of Accelerometers in Determining Knee-Flexion Angles During Sitting in a Laboratory Setting
Yanlin Wu, Myles W. O’Brien, Alexander Peddle, W. Seth Daley, Beverly D. Schwartz, Derek S. Kimmerly, and Ryan J. Frayne
Moving Beyond the Characterization of Activity Intensity Bouts as Square Waves Signals
Myles W. O’Brien, Jennifer L. Petterson, Liam P. Pellerine, Madeline E. Shivgulam, Derek S. Kimmerly, Ryan J. Frayne, Pasan Hettiarachchi, and Peter J. Johansson
Wearable activity monitors provide objective estimates of time in different physical activity intensities. Each continuous stepping period is described by its length and a corresponding single intensity (in metabolic equivalents of task [METs]), creating square wave–shaped signals. We argue that physiological responses do not resemble square waves, with the purpose of this technical report to challenge this idea and use experimental data as a proof of concept and direct potential solutions to better characterize activity intensity. Healthy adults (n = 43, 19♀; 23 ± 5 years) completed 6-min treadmill stages (five walking and five jogging/running) where oxygen consumption (3.5 ml O2·kg−1·min−1 = 1 MET) was recorded throughout and following the cessation of stepping. The time to steady state was ∼1–1.5 min, and time back to baseline following exercise was ∼1–2 min, with faster stepping stages generally exhibiting longer durations. Instead of square waves, the duration intensity signal reflected a trapezoid shape for each stage. The METs per minute during the rise to steady state (upstroke slopes; average: 1.7–6.3 METs/min for slow walking to running) may be used to better characterize activity intensity for shorter activity bouts where steady state is not achieved (within ∼90 s). While treating each activity bout as a single intensity is a much simpler analytical procedure, characterizing each bout in a continuous manner may better reflect the true physiological responses to movement. The information provided herein may be used to improve the characterization of activity intensity, definition of bout breaks, and act as a starting point for researchers and software developers interested in using wearables to measure activity intensity.
